Are Paper Stock Certificates Necessary for Startups?

Do Startups Need to Issue Paper Stock Certificates?

The short answer? No, they don’t. Legally, in states like Delaware (where many startups call home), companies can skip paper and go with “uncertificated” shares—essentially, digital ownership records. If your incorporation documents say so, you’re set to go paper-free.

The digital route is easier, faster, and cheaper than dealing with physical certificates. You can track shares in real-time and issue new ones with a click. Plus, with software like Stellar App, managing ownership is practically a breeze—no need to ship, file, or track physical paper.

But if you’re wondering why paper stock certificates are still a “thing” in 2024, let’s take a quick look back…

Why Paper Certificates Are Still a Thing (And Why They’re Rarely Used)

Paper stock certificates go way back. They were used before computers, emails, or even faxes, when people needed physical proof of ownership. They were literally printed proof that said, “Hey, I own a piece of this company.” Back in those days, if you wanted to transfer shares, you showed up in person with the certificate in hand.

Fast forward a few decades, and the shift to digital stock records came from an unlikely place—not startups, but big brokerage firms. In the 1980s, big brokerage firms got fed up with the expense of printing, mailing, and managing certificates for every transaction. Eventually, new laws allowed public companies to manage everything electronically.

Today, startups use digital records to manage their ownership. It’s efficient, clean, and scales well as companies grow. But there are still a few reasons companies might stick with the old-fashioned paper route…

So, What Are the Benefits of Paper Stock Certificates?

For most investors and founders, digital records are enough. But paper stock certificates have a few unique perks:

1. Tangible Proof of Ownership
   For some investors, especially traditional ones, holding a paper certificate feels... real. There’s something about having physical proof of your investment that makes it feel more secure.
2. That Old-School Charm
   Back in the day, certificates were works of art. Companies used to print elaborate designs, sometimes customized to show off their industry—think trains on railroad stocks. Today, a physical certificate can feel like a collector’s item, especially if it’s from a groundbreaking or sentimental startup.
3. Investor Relations
   If you’re a family-owned startup or have private backers, giving investors a paper certificate can feel like a personal gesture. It’s a tangible sign of respect and appreciation—like a graduation diploma, but for startup investments.

For most startups today, though, these benefits don’t outweigh the simplicity and ease of going paperless.

Do I Need a Stock Certificate, or Is a Contract Enough to Protect My Investment?

Let’s talk about protection. Some investors wonder if a stock certificate gives them more security than a contract alone. Here’s what you need to know:

• Contracts outline the terms—including rights, obligations, and the transfer of ownership. They are legally binding and establish your ownership stake in the company.
• Stock Certificates (or, more often these days, digital records) serve as formal evidence of that ownership. They can be useful if ownership is ever in question or for your personal records.

For peace of mind, it's beneficial to have both: a contract that clearly outlines the deal and establishes your ownership, plus a digital or paper certificate that serves as formal evidence of your stake in the company. Many investors feel better knowing their name is logged in both places.

How Do Startups Issue Stock Certificates Today?

In case you’re a founder ready to issue stock, here’s how startups typically handle the process:

1. Decide on Paper or Digital
   Want to issue physical certificates? You’ll need a printer and a whole lot of patience. Most startups today go digital from the start.
2. Create and Update the Cap Table
   A cap table is the master list of who owns what in your company. Platforms like Carta or Stellar(yes, that's us) make this simple—think of it as an investor roster that updates in real-time.
3. Prepare Certificates
   For paper certificates, this means creating a custom document with the investor’s name, the number of shares, and your company’s seal. For digital certificates, platforms like ours do the heavy lifting for you—no postage required.
4. Keep Everyone Updated
   Whether you’re issuing paper or digital certificates, keeping the cap table and investor records up to date is crucial. If anything changes with their shares, your investors should be in the loop.

Paper Certificates or Paper-Free?

For today’s startups, the choice between paper and digital isn’t that complicated. Paper stock certificates aren’t a legal requirement, and they add cost, complexity, and paperwork that few people actually want to deal with. Still, some founders may want to stick to paper if they have a traditional investor base or just like the idea of physical documentation.

If you’re deciding whether to go with paper or digital certificates, consider:

• Your Investor Base: Will they appreciate a physical memento, or are they happy with an email?
• Cost and Convenience: Physical certificates require more time, money, and management.
• Legal Simplicity: Digital records are straightforward, secure, and easy to update—no risk of losing paper or messy record-keeping.

In 2024, digital records are the way forward for most startups. They simplify ownership, streamline compliance, and save time for everyone involved. But hey—if you love tradition, there’s nothing stopping you from printing a few certificates on that fancy paper. Just be prepared for some extra legwork.

‍
Looking to launch a startup or issue digital shares for your startup? Contact Us Today.